A Motion to Suppress Evidence is a crucial legal document filed with the court to exclude evidence obtained illegally or in violation of a defendant's constitutional rights. This motion is a critical tool in criminal defense, potentially impacting the outcome of a case significantly. This guide provides a sample motion and explains the key elements involved in crafting a successful one.
Understanding the Basis for a Motion to Suppress
Before delving into the sample, it’s vital to understand the grounds upon which a motion to suppress is typically based. These often involve violations of the Fourth, Fifth, and Sixth Amendments to the US Constitution.
-
Fourth Amendment Violations: This amendment protects against unreasonable searches and seizures. Evidence obtained through an illegal search or seizure (without a warrant, consent, or probable cause) is often inadmissible. Examples include illegal entry into a home, warrantless vehicle searches, or improperly conducted searches incident to arrest.
-
Fifth Amendment Violations: This amendment protects against self-incrimination. Evidence obtained through coerced confessions or statements made without proper Miranda warnings is subject to suppression.
-
Sixth Amendment Violations: This amendment guarantees the right to counsel. Evidence obtained through questioning after the right to counsel has attached, without the presence of an attorney, may be suppressed. This also includes instances where the defendant's right to counsel was deliberately circumvented.
-
Fruit of the Poisonous Tree Doctrine: Even if the initial illegality is relatively minor, any evidence derived from it (the "fruit") can also be suppressed. This includes evidence discovered as a direct result of illegally obtained information.
Sample Motion to Suppress Evidence
IN THE [COURT NAME] [COUNTY/STATE]
STATE OF [STATE] v. [DEFENDANT'S NAME] Case No.: [CASE NUMBER]
MOTION TO SUPPRESS EVIDENCE
COMES NOW, the Defendant, [Defendant's Name], by and through undersigned counsel, and hereby moves this Honorable Court to suppress certain evidence obtained by the State in violation of Defendant’s constitutional rights, specifically the Fourth, Fifth, and/or Sixth Amendments to the United States Constitution.
I. INTRODUCTION
The Defendant was arrested on [Date] and charged with [Charges]. The State intends to introduce certain evidence at trial. This evidence, however, was obtained illegally and in violation of the Defendant's constitutional rights, as detailed below.
II. FACTS
[This section provides a detailed factual account of the events leading to the acquisition of the evidence. Be specific and precise. Include dates, times, locations, names of officers involved, and a clear description of the evidence sought to be suppressed. For example:]
On [Date], at approximately [Time], law enforcement officers [Names of officers] conducted a search of [Location] without a warrant and without the Defendant's consent. During this search, they seized [Evidence seized]. The Defendant was subsequently arrested and interrogated without being advised of his Miranda rights. During the interrogation, the Defendant made incriminating statements. These statements were obtained in violation of his Fifth Amendment right against self-incrimination.
III. ARGUMENT
The evidence described above should be suppressed because it was obtained in violation of [Specify the violated constitutional rights]. The search of [Location] was illegal because [Explain why the search was illegal – lack of warrant, consent, probable cause, etc.]. Furthermore, the statements made by the Defendant were obtained in violation of his Miranda rights because [Explain the violation of Miranda rights]. The evidence is "fruit of the poisonous tree" because [Explain how the evidence is connected to the initial illegality].
IV. RELIEF REQUESTED
WHEREFORE, the Defendant respectfully requests that this Honorable Court grant the Motion to Suppress Evidence and order the suppression of [Specifically identify the evidence to be suppressed].
Respectfully submitted,
[Attorney Name] [Attorney Contact Information]
Crafting an Effective Motion
This sample is a template. You must adapt it to your specific case. The key to a strong motion is:
- Detailed Factual Narrative: Present a clear and concise timeline of events leading to the evidence's acquisition.
- Legal Argumentation: Connect the facts to specific legal precedents and case law supporting your claim of constitutional violations.
- Specific Evidence Identification: Clearly state what evidence should be suppressed.
- Proof: Include supporting evidence like police reports, witness statements, and affidavits.
Disclaimer: This sample motion is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. You must consult with a qualified attorney to discuss your specific case and prepare a legally sound motion to suppress evidence. The laws governing evidence suppression vary by jurisdiction.
