This cheat sheet provides judges with concise, constructive comments to offer debaters and speakers across various speech and debate events. Remember to tailor your feedback to the specific event and the individual performance. Focus on both strengths and areas for improvement, offering specific examples to support your assessment.
General Comments Applicable Across Events:
-
Strengths:
- Strong Argumentation/Case: "Your argument regarding [specific point] was particularly compelling due to [reason, e.g., strong evidence, logical structure]."
- Effective Delivery: "Your delivery was engaging and confident, maintaining excellent eye contact and pacing."
- Clear and Concise Language: "You used clear and concise language, making your points easily understandable."
- Excellent Organization: "Your speech/case was exceptionally well-organized, with a clear introduction, body, and conclusion."
- Compelling Storytelling: (For speeches involving narrative) "Your storytelling was captivating and effectively conveyed your message."
- Thorough Research: "Your research was evident in the depth and breadth of your arguments and evidence."
- Effective Rebuttal/Refutation: (For debate) "Your rebuttals effectively addressed your opponent's arguments, highlighting key weaknesses."
- Poised and Professional: "You maintained a poised and professional demeanor throughout the competition."
-
Areas for Improvement:
- Argumentation/Case: "Consider strengthening your argument on [specific point] by [suggestion, e.g., adding more evidence, addressing counterarguments]."
- Delivery: "Improving your pacing and modulation would enhance your delivery's impact." Or "Try incorporating more gestures to emphasize key points."
- Clarity: "Some points could benefit from clearer articulation and explanation."
- Organization: "Consider reorganizing your speech/case for a more logical flow."
- Evidence: "While your evidence was relevant, consider incorporating a wider range of sources for greater credibility."
- Rebuttal/Refutation: "Focus on directly addressing your opponent's key arguments rather than tangential issues."
- Time Management: "Work on time management to ensure you cover all your points effectively within the allotted time."
- Handling Interruptions: (For debate) "Practice techniques to manage interruptions and maintain control of the debate."
Event-Specific Comments:
These are examples; adapt them based on the specific round and performance:
Public Forum Debate:
- Strengths: "Your team effectively utilized crossfire to highlight the weaknesses in your opponent's arguments." "Your summary effectively synthesized your team's main points and contrasted them with your opponent's."
- Areas for Improvement: "Focus on more clearly defining the resolution and framing your arguments within that context." "Develop stronger rebuttals that directly address your opponent's specific claims."
Lincoln-Douglas Debate:
- Strengths: "Your value framework was clearly articulated and consistently applied throughout the round." "Your analysis of the philosophical implications was insightful and well-supported."
- Areas for Improvement: "Explore alternative interpretations of the resolution and their impact on your value structure." "Develop stronger responses to your opponent's framework challenges."
Policy Debate:
- Strengths: "Your team presented a well-developed plan with clear solvency mechanisms." "Your responses to kritiks were well-articulated and effectively addressed the core concerns."
- Areas for Improvement: "Consider strengthening your evidence on [specific claim] with more recent and credible sources." "Develop a more robust defense against potential disadvantages to your plan."
Original Oratory/Informative Speaking:
- Strengths: "Your captivating narrative style kept the audience engaged throughout." "Your use of visual aids enhanced understanding and retention."
- Areas for Improvement: "Consider refining your introduction to better grab the audience's attention." "Ensure a smoother transition between different sections of your speech."
Impromptu Speaking:
- Strengths: "You responded effectively to the prompt, demonstrating thoughtful analysis and organization." "Your use of examples and analogies strengthened your arguments."
- Areas for Improvement: "Focus on developing a clearer thesis statement to guide your argument." "Practice brainstorming techniques to generate more ideas quickly."
Remember to be specific, provide actionable advice, and maintain a positive and encouraging tone. Your comments should help debaters and speakers improve their skills and confidence.
